Traditional GPS Tracking vs. SIM-Based Tracking A Comparative Analysis

Two frequently utilized techniques for monitoring and tracking vehicles in fleet management are traditional GPS tracking and SIM-based tracking. Although both strategies accomplish the same goal, there are significant variations in the technology and functioning of each.

The Global Positioning System (GPS) satellites are used in conventional GPS tracking to identify the location, speed, and path of the vehicle. It entails installing GPS equipment in the cars, which then transmits the data to a centralized system after receiving signals from the GPS satellites. Using fleet management software or web-based platforms, fleet managers may view the position of the vehicle and related data.

Pros of Traditional GPS Tracking

Accurate Location Tracking: Traditional GPS tracking provides precise location information, allowing fleet managers to monitor vehicle movements effectively.

Established Technology: GPS technology has been widely adopted and proven effective in fleet management, ensuring reliable tracking results.

Speed Detection: The GPS Insight speedometer is a GPS device that calculates speed using point to point GPS measurement, which is done by analyzing the straight-line distance traversed by the vehicle between two geographic points and dividing this by the time traveled to get the mph of the vehicle.

Cons of Traditional GPS Tracking

Internet Dependency: GPS ‘s 100% Dependency on Internet makes it ineffective in remote areas. The End customer must pay a hefty amount for the device, moreover it’s Installation is also cumbersome.

Data Delay : There might be a slight delay in transmitting and updating vehicle data due to the reliance on satellite communication.

SIM (Subscriber Identity Module) cards, like those used in cell phones, are used in SIM-based tracking to track, and communicate vehicle data. A tracking device put in the vehicle is equipped with a SIM card that enables data transmission through cellular networks. Through fleet management software or mobile applications, fleet managers may access real-time vehicle data.

Pros of SIM-Based Tracking

Wide Coverage: SIM-based tracking leverages cellular networks, providing broader coverage compared to traditional GPS tracking, even in areas with limited satellite reception.

Real-Time Tracking: SIM-based tracking offers instant updates on vehicle location and status, allowing fleet managers to make timely decisions and respond to situations promptly.

Simplified Setup: SIM-based tracking eliminates the need for dedicated GPS hardware, as it relies on readily available cellular network infrastructure.

Cons of SIM-Based Tracking

Ongoing Data Costs: SIM-based tracking requires a cellular data plan, which incurs ongoing costs based on data usage. The expenses associated with data plans should be considered when implementing SIM-based tracking.

Dependency on Cellular Networks: In areas with weak or no cellular coverage, SIM-based tracking may face challenges in transmitting data, potentially leading to temporary data gaps.

The best tracking technique to use will rely on your fleet management needs, your geographic coverage needs, and your financial constraints. Sim-based tracking is the best option for fleets operating in locations with poor satellite service or needing immediate tracking information since it gives real-time updates and a wider coverage area than traditional GPS tracking. Fleet managers may choose a tracking solution that fits their goals and budget by analyzing the operational requirements and weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Related Post

Blog White Logo

Fleataable: The best fleet and transport management software in india that will help you manage all aspects of your fleet, from drivers and vehicles to simple maintenance and repairs. You’ll be able to track everything in a single place

Head Office

601, JMD Galleria, Sohna Road, Sector 48, Gurugram, Haryana, India (122018)

Branch Office

Guelph, Ontario, Canada

© 2023 Affable Web Solutions Company. All rights reserved